New Listing For Rent!
Secluded Large Modern home on Indian Hill Road

Vacation on Martha’s Vineyard in a modern vacation rental home in West Tisbury. Close to Lambert’s Cove Beach and many attractions on Indian Hill Road. Newly completed in 2019, this stunning colonial home in West Tisbury is fully equipped with all the modern amenities in an open floor plan with plenty of space for all. “Sunnyside” is located in a very private and quiet 4.3 acre wooded compound. The Main House is sited on on top of a tall hill and above the surrounding countryside. It is surrounded by mature beech and oak trees giving it the feeling of a tree house, open to the breezes that blow through the trees.

Enjoy the gourmet kitchen with top of the line LG appliances. The large kitchen island with comfortable seating is perfect for interacting with your friends and family while you prepare a delicious meal. The furnishings were professionally selected and are by Restoration Hardware. They grace and compliment each room perfectly. This four level home can take a crowd and also be comfortable for a couple or two that want their own private spaces. These number a lovely front porch with seating, a back deck, a large side porch covered in cedar, a kitchen peninsula with seating for 6 and a garden level game and media room.

The home has central air conditioning that’s controllable from every level as well as smart home technology to make managing the heat, cooling and lights and environment effortless.

The main home was originally built in 2002 but presents as new after a compete top to bottom renovation. Their are all new walls, floors, windows, doors and appliances.
The large open first floor has a wonderful kitchen island seating area, living room and dining area.
The second floor features a master suite and two large bedrooms.
The third floor is wide open and ready for anything.
The Garden Level features a game room, ping pong table and pull out sofa bed.

The entire property incorporates the following buildings

(note the Cottage and Compound is sold out until June 1, 2021)

THE MAIN HOUSE – SLEEPS 10+ [5 bed 4 bath]
GUEST COTTAGE – SLEEPS 8+ [4 bed 2 bath]
FAMILY COMPOUND – SLEEPS 16+ [9 bed 6 bath]


This elegant and luxurious home is located in West Tisbury on the beautiful island of Martha’s Vineyard. It is located off of desirable Indian Hill Road near Arrowhead Farm. This large equestrian center is open to the public. The property is also just down the road from Cedar Tree Neck, one of the island’s most beautiful walking trail systems. You are also near the world famous Polly Hill Arboretum and of course the fantastic Lambert’s Cove Beach. There is an available 11 passenger van with beach sticker as well.

We are also just five miles west of the Vineyard Haven Ferry Terminal and seven miles northwest of the Martha’s Vineyard Airport, allowing you to easily reach the house no matter how you arrive. The beautiful shores of Lambert’s Cove Beach are two miles north, and the many attractions of downtown Oak Bluffs – from the historic Flying Horses to Inkwell Beach – are eight miles east. Edgartown is a short drive down the Edgartown road where there is ample public parking and transportation options. You can even ride your bike their through the State Forest.

Purchase This Property

133 Indian Hill Road in West Tisbury

Privacy and quiet are the hallmarks of this family compound nestled in the woods on the North Shore of West Tisbury on the beautiful island of Martha’s Vineyard.

The property is 4.35 acres and has four structures on it. A 5 bedroom main house, a three bedroom guest house, a music studio and a two story art studio.

The main house was built in 2002 and is a four story five bedroom colonial. It has a footprint of 40 x 28, resulting in over 4,000 of living space.
The home was completely renovated from 2017 through 2018 and features completely new baths, kitchens, windows, doors, kitchen and appliances
The home was foam insulated and is now very energy efficient
There is a full poured foundation with 6 large windows looking towards the south resulting in a sunny and welcoming ground floor
The 1st floor is an open plan L shape with a large living room, dining room and gourmet itchen. There is also a private bedroom/study with a en-suite bath and zero clearance shower
The 2nd floor has a large master bedroom with en-suite bath. Laundry facities, owners storage closet and two bedrooms with large closets and a shared bath
The 3rd floor is fully furnished and has two large rooms with tall ceilings.

The cottage guest house was built in 1998 and is listed by the town as a two bedroom home. The footprint is approximately 600 sq. Ft. and may be able to be expanded to 1000 sq ft. according to recent changes in West Tisbury zoning. It is currently configured as a 3 bedroom with a bath on the first floor and another in the partially finished walkout basement.
All new kitchen, rugs, paint and furnishings have been done.

The Music Studio is the third structure of approximately 300 sq ft which has a refridgerator, insulation and heat, Water is provided seasonally via connections to the cottage.

The Tree House is the fourth structure of approximately 300 sq ft. This structure is partially finished and could be a studio, office or guest bedroom.

There is an enhanced title 5 septic designed for 6 bedrooms. The site will allow for as many bedrooms as desired so long as leaching field is enhanced. The property can also support a barn and a pool

You can see the original listing here.